LATEST CASE LAWS UNDER GST – 20.11.2026 – A2Z TAXCORP LLP

LATEST GST CASE LAWS: 20.11.2026

🔥📛 SC upholds entertainment duty on commercial jewellery exhibitions; Affirms that ‘entertainment’ extends beyond conventional performances

➡️ The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal of the Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council against the Bombay High Court’s judgment and held that the business-to-business trade exhibitions organised under the banners of IIJS and IIJS Signature fall within the definition of ‘entertainment’ in Section 2(a) of the Bombay Entertainments Duty Act, 1923 and are exigible to entertainment duty under Section 3.

➡️ The High Court had held that an exhibition need not involve a musical or ramp performance to qualify as entertainment where it has a public character, provides gratification and admission is against payment. Referring to Geeta Enterprises, it noted that an event has public colour if it is open to the public or a defined segment of it, that gratification includes monetary benefit to exhibitors, and that the identity of the person deriving pleasure is irrelevant.

➡️ The High Court had rejected the contention that trade shows, being business platforms rather than recreational events, fall outside the levy, observing that the statutory definition is inclusive and wide enough to cover exhibitions, even those of an educative character. It distinguished the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s ruling in Calico Mills, where a nominal entry fee was adjusted against purchases, noting the Council’s large-scale events with substantial registration charges and significant commercial benefits, and rejected the refund claim.

➡️ Expressing full agreement with the High Court, the Supreme Court examined Section 2(a) in light of Union Medical Agency, Bharat Coop. Bank and Forest Range Officer, and held that an exhibition, performance, amusement, game or sport to which persons are admitted for payment falls within the definition. The words ‘to which persons are admitted for payment’ are the deciding factor, so where entry is on payment the event cannot be taken out of the definition merely because it is a business-to-business transaction.

➡️ The Court further held that administrative requirements for entry, such as filling up forms for security and other purposes, cannot be used to wriggle out of the plain reading of Section 2(a). Organisers of paid-entry trade fairs remain exposed to legacy entertainment duty demands for the pre-GST period even where the event has no recreational content.

✔️ SC – The Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council vs The State of Maharashtra and Others [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1889 OF 2015]

🔥📛 Allahabad HC stays online gaming demand, flags prima facie conflict with Gameskraft verdict

➡️ The Allahabad High Court granted interim relief to Skillwin Technology, which provides online gaming services such as Play Rummy, by staying an order raising a demand under Section 74 of the CGST Act, observing that the order appears to have been passed in the teeth of the Supreme Court’s decision in Gameskraft Technologies.

➡️ The assessee contended that despite cooperating with the investigation and disclosing the taxable amount on cash added by players, the Revenue rejected its claim for non-furnishing of player-wise ledgers, without relying on any supporting evidence or material.

➡️ The assessee argued that, after the Gameskraft verdict, Rule 31B, which adopts a deposit-based valuation mechanism for online money gaming, applies retrospectively, so its valuation could not be said to be wrong. Rule 31B was inserted by Notification No. 51/2023-Central Tax dated September 29, 2023, effective October 1, 2023.

➡️ The assessee also alleged the absence of foundational facts such as suppression, concealment, misstatement or fraud needed to invoke Section 74, and non-compliance with paragraph 86 of Gameskraft, under which the SCNs of September 2022 were restored, assessees were given liberty to file replies and raise factual and legal submissions, and adjudicating authorities were directed to decide in accordance with law and the findings in the judgment.

➡️ The Revenue raised a preliminary objection of alternate remedy. Taking note of the prima facie inconsistency with the Supreme Court’s directions, the Court directed the Revenue to file a counter-affidavit within four weeks and stayed the operation and effect of the order dated August 20, 2026 until further orders.

✔️ Allahabad HC – Skillwin Technology Private Limited and anr vs UOI & ors [WRIT TAX No. – 4488 of 2026]

🔥📛 AP HC stays ITC recovery, questions Revenue’s reliance on FASTag data to dispute goods movement

➡️ The Andhra Pradesh High Court granted an interim stay of all further proceedings under a Section 74 show cause notice dated August 21, 2026, in a case where the Revenue disputed the movement of goods on the basis of missing FASTag data at toll plazas.

➡️ The Court held that the Revenue’s contention regarding missing FASTag data prima facie merits no consideration, in view of the MoRTH press release dated December 31, 2020 clarifying that despite mandatory FASTag fitment from January 1, 2021, hybrid lanes at National Highway fee plazas would continue to permit payment of toll through both FASTag and cash. It also observed that on a plain reading the SCN contains no allegation of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax.

➡️ The assessee had purchased palladium carbon from a registered Chennai supplier under invoices, transported by road to its Visakhapatnam factory, with vehicle numbers and e-way bills recorded in its gate entry register. About four and a half years later, following a direction to investigate recipients of four firms found to be non-existent, the Revenue issued DRC-01A demanding ₹59.16 lakh for February and May 2021 alleging ‘no movement of goods’, and then the SCN, despite the assessee furnishing invoices, registers, bank statements and GSTR-2A/2B.

➡️ The assessee contended that Section 74 cannot be invoked without any allegation of fraud or suppression, that all payments were through banking channels and reflected in the supplier’s returns, and that mere absence of clear proof of movement cannot justify Section 74, particularly when limitation under Section 73 had expired, relying on Tata Steel Ltd. The Revenue argued that ITC was deliberately availed without receipt of goods and that the supplier’s registration was cancelled retrospectively.

➡️ Noting that purchase under valid invoices was undisputed and that the assessee had furnished complete details of movement including vehicle numbers and e-way bills, the Court held that the matter requires further consideration and directed the Revenue to file its counter-affidavit. Absence of FASTag records is therefore not, by itself, proof that goods did not move.

✔️ Andhra Pradesh HC – Arora Matthey Limited Versus The Deputy Commissioner (Anti-Evasion) [WP No. 32237 of 2026]

🔥📛 SC: Reserves judgment in Revenue’s challenge to 12% interest on CENVAT-refund from payment till disbursement

➡️ The Supreme Court reserved judgment in the Revenue’s Special Leave Petition against the Madhya Pradesh High Court judgment, which dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against CESTAT’s grant of 12% interest on a refund of CENVAT credit from the date of payment till disbursement.

➡️ The assessee, engaged in setting up and managing malls, had availed CENVAT credit on inputs such as cement, steel, angles and channels and on input services including construction, consultancy and architectural services used in mall construction, which was initially denied.

➡️ CESTAT, by its Final Order dated September 1, 2021, held that the restriction on credit for inputs and input services used in construction of buildings or civil structures, introduced from April 1, 2011, did not apply retrospectively, and allowed credit availed before that date, remanding the matter for quantification.

➡️ On re-adjudication, a refund of ₹7.15 crore was sanctioned under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act read with Section 83 of the Finance Act and Section 142(8)(b) of the CGST Act, but interest was denied because the refund was sanctioned within three months of the application. By its Final Order dated January 11, 2024, CESTAT reversed that denial and granted 12% interest from the date of payment till disbursement.

➡️ Before the High Court the Revenue contended that CESTAT misconstrued Sections 11B, 11BB, 35F and 35FF and wrongly relied on Mafatlal Industries and Sandvik Asia to grant interest without statutory basis. The High Court held that no substantial question of law arose, the issue being covered by Green Valley Industries (Meghalaya HC) and Riba Textiles (Punjab and Haryana HC). The Supreme Court’s decision will settle the rate and period of interest on such legacy refunds.

✔️ SC – CGST and Central Excise vs M/s Indore Treasure Market City Pvt Ltd [Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 576/2025]

🔥📛 Madras HC hears insurance companies on ITC availment for insurance facilitation and vehicle repairs

➡️ The Madras High Court heard a batch of Revenue appeals on whether general insurance companies can claim CENVAT credit of service tax paid on repairs of insured vehicles by authorised service stations, and agreed to hear the matter further.

➡️ Explaining how motor claims are settled, the insurers submitted that they have arrangements with authorised service stations, that a surveyor appointed by the insurer assesses the damage and agrees the repair cost, and that the insurer pays its share either directly under the cashless scheme or by reimbursing the insured. Credit is claimed only on the portion of the repair cost borne by the insurer, and the expense is incurred in providing the output general insurance service, making it an input service.

➡️ Countering the Revenue’s stand that the vehicle owner is the recipient, the insurers argued that CESTAT rightly distinguished between recipient and beneficiary, since the service station’s contract is with the insurer. They relied on the Tribunal’s ruling concerning Western Union’s domestic agents and the ‘grandma’s flowers’ illustration in Australian GST Ruling GSTR 2006/9 to submit that the person who contracts and pays for a service is its recipient even if a third party enjoys the benefit.

➡️ The insurers also relied on the TRU letter dated February 26, 2010, which clarifies in the context of health insurance that an insurer paying a hospital is the service receiver entitled to credit, and argued that no artificial distinction can be drawn for motor insurance. On the insured’s freedom to choose a garage, they contended that after an accident the owner holds the vehicle as bailee of the insurer and that the cashless facility is available only at network stations.

➡️ On the motor vehicle exclusion in Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, the insurers pointed out that it was introduced only from April 1, 2011, whereas all disputed periods ended by March 31, 2011. They added that the recipient’s name is not an essential invoice particular under the proviso to Rule 9(2), that they hold the original invoices, that the earlier demands are time-barred, and that the Revenue had accepted orders such as Royal Sundaram which had attained finality.

✔️ Madras HC – COMMISSIONER OF GST AND CENTRAL EXCISE VS M/S. UNITED INDIA INS CO LTD & Ors

🔥📛 Bombay HC stays coercive recovery arising solely from reporting eligible IGST credit under CGST/SGST heads

➡️ The Bombay High Court issued notice and stayed coercive recovery under an Order-in-Original in a writ petition challenging a GST demand of over ₹24 crore, confirmed under Section 73 only because the assessee had reported eligible IGST credit under the CGST and SGST heads in its GSTR-3B returns for FY 2018-19.

➡️ The Order-in-Original itself records that the assessee short-availed IGST credit by the same amount as it over-reported CGST and SGST credit, so no excess credit was availed on an aggregate basis. The Revenue nonetheless confirmed the demand on the grounds that IGST, CGST and SGST are distinct components of tax, that revenue neutrality does not cure a wrong availment, and that the departmental view is that credit cannot be reported across heads.

➡️ The assessee argued that there is no loss of revenue because its entitlement to IGST credit is undisputed and correct reporting would have left the liability under each head and the cash paid unchanged, relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Coca-Cola India. It submitted that ITC operates as a fungible pool, since Section 49(5)(a) permits IGST credit to be used against CGST and SGST and Section 49A read with Rule 88A requires IGST credit to be exhausted first, so Section 49 regulates the order of utilisation and not the head under which credit is entered.

➡️ The assessee relied on Circular Nos. 98/17/2019-GST and 192/04/2023-GST, the latter clarifying that IGST, CGST and SGST balances in the electronic credit ledger are considered together for computing interest on wrongly availed IGST credit, and pointed out that the Revenue’s own officers had dropped identical demands against its group entities. It also cited a consistent line of Kerala and Madras High Court judgments holding that the electronic credit ledger is a unified source.

➡️ The Revenue argued that the assessee did not use its opportunity to rectify its returns and that CGST and SGST credit availed at this stage contravenes Section 16 as there is no underlying supply. After hearing the parties, the Court issued notice and stayed any coercive recovery, offering interim protection to taxpayers facing demands founded purely on wrong-head reporting of otherwise eligible credit.

✔️ Bombay HC – Mediaedge CIA India Pvt. Ltd. Versus Union of India & Ors. [WRIT PETITION NO. 5109 OF 2026]

🔥📛 SC posts Revenue’s challenge to Tripura HC judgment reading down Section 16(2)(c) for final disposal

➡️ The Supreme Court listed for final disposal on January 21, 2027 the Revenue’s Special Leave Petition challenging the Tripura High Court judgment that read down Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act to protect bona fide recipients from denial of ITC on account of the supplier’s failure to deposit tax.

➡️ The listing follows the Revenue’s submission that a resolution through the GST Council may take considerable time, as the States are yet to come on board.

➡️ The Additional Solicitor General informed the Court that the Council has deferred its decision by three months and that the outcome remains uncertain even after that period, and submitted that the matter should therefore proceed to arguments.

➡️ At the earlier hearing the Court had stayed the operation of the Tripura High Court judgment and deferred consideration of the SLP to allow the Officers’ Committee constituted by the 57th GST Council to examine a possible resolution to the denial of ITC to bona fide recipients for suppliers’ tax defaults.

➡️ The Supreme Court has also issued notice in Sumetco Alloys against the Rajasthan High Court judgment dismissing a challenge to the constitutional validity of Section 16(2)(c). With no administrative solution in sight, the question of protection for bona fide purchasers will be decided by the Court, and the Tripura ruling remains stayed in the meantime.

✔️ SC – Union of India & Ors Vs Sahil Enterprises & Anr. [Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 31573/2026]

🔥📛 HC: Supplier’s bill trading alone cannot sustain Section 74 notice without evidence of recipient’s fraud

➡️ The Karnataka High Court allowed the assessee’s writ appeal against the Single Judge’s order relegating it to the appellate remedy under Section 107, and set aside an Order-in-Original passed under Section 74 for FY 2019-20 that was founded on the supplier’s circular or bill trading.

➡️ Referring to the Supreme Court’s decisions in G.R. Infraprojects and Tata Steel, which require foundational facts of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression to be established before the extended period can be invoked, the Court held that the SCN was bereft of any reasoning as to what fraud or misstatement was attributable to the assessee. It pointed only to the supplier’s bill trading, which came to light three years after the transaction.

➡️ The assessee had received an ASMT-10 intimation alleging that its supplier was engaged in bill trading and filed a detailed reply with tax invoices. The Revenue nevertheless issued DRC-01A recording that no reply had been filed, and then an SCN under Section 74(1) again recording that the assessee had neither paid nor objected, although it had replied.

➡️ The Order-in-Original denied ITC under Section 16(2)(b) on the ground that lorry receipts and the supplier’s weighment slips were not produced, and raised a demand with interest and 100% penalty. The Court noted that the order did not even examine whether a reply had been filed, and emphasised that the issue was not the order but the very initiation of proceedings under Section 74.

➡️ Holding that the initiation of proceedings ran contrary to the law laid down by the Supreme Court, the Court set aside the Single Judge’s order and the Order-in-Original, directed refund of the assessee’s deposit, and granted the Revenue liberty to proceed, only if available in law, from the stage of considering the reply to the first notice. A supplier’s fraud cannot by itself supply the ingredients of Section 74 against the recipient.

✔️ Karnataka HC – Kunal Traders vs State of Karnataka & Ors [WRIT APPEAL NO. 100484 OF 2026 (T-RES)]

🔥📛 HC: Upholds Rule 36(4), declines to quash SCNs proposing ITC reversal under the Rule

➡️ The Rajasthan High Court dismissed writ petitions challenging the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules and the show cause notices proposing ITC reversal for mismatch between the ITC availed by the assessee and the amounts reflected in GSTR-2A.

➡️ Rule 36(4), inserted on October 9, 2019, restricted ITC on invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers to 20% of the eligible credit reflected in uploaded invoices, and the limit was reduced to 10% with effect from January 1, 2020 by Notification dated December 26, 2019.

➡️ The assessee contended that the Rule is ultra vires Section 16, which does not contemplate restricting ITC for a supplier’s failure to upload invoice details once the recipient has satisfied the conditions in Section 16(2). The Revenue submitted that the Rule is a valid policy measure framed under Sections 16 and 164 on the GST Council’s recommendation to curb fraudulent ITC, and that ITC is a statutory concession and not a vested right.

➡️ Noting that the Gauhati High Court in High Tech Ecogreen Contractors LLP, the Madras High Court in L. & T. Geostructure LLP and the Kerala High Court in Nahasshukoor have already upheld the Rule, the Court expressed respectful agreement with those views and saw no reason to take a contrary one.

➡️ Since the challenge to the SCNs rested on the challenge to the Rule, it also failed, and relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Trillion Lead Factory Pvt. Ltd. the Court held that a writ ordinarily does not lie against the mere issuance of an SCN. The assessee was given liberty to challenge any adverse assessment order in accordance with law or, where proceedings are pending, to appear before the authorities and place its material on record.

✔️ Rajasthan HC – Ravi Infrabuild Projects Pvt. Ltd Vs Union Of India & Anr [D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 3559/2020]

🔥📛 GSTAT: ITC from non-existent supplier registered on forged rent deed is fraudulent; Upholds Sec. 74 invocation

➡️ GSTAT Cuttack dismissed the assessee’s appeal and upheld the denial of ITC on two invoices, together with tax, interest and penalty under Section 74, holding that the supplier was non-existent and the transactions were mere paper transactions without any underlying supply of goods.

➡️ The Enforcement Wing’s investigation showed that the person named as the supplier’s proprietor disowned the business, the GST registration, the bank account and the e-way bills, while the owner of the declared premises denied letting it out and stated that the signatories to the rent agreement, his late father and uncle, had died long before its execution. Registration was granted in August 2020 and the transactions took place in September 2020.

➡️ The Tribunal held that registration obtained on a forged rent agreement is void ab initio, and that once non-existence of any business at the registered place and procurement of registration by fraud is established, complicity of the recipient availing ITC on such invoices follows as a natural corollary, attracting Section 74. Since supply is an essential ingredient of input tax under Section 2(62), no supply can materialise from a non-existent supplier.

➡️ The assessee, a manufacturer of rolled steel, relied on invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips from its own vehicle and bank statements, but did not produce the stock register, purchase and sale registers, ITC ledger or transport challans when asked. The Tribunal held that these documents neither rebut the supplier’s non-existence nor prove receipt of goods under Section 16(2)(b), noted that payment by bearer cheques showed no corresponding credit to the supplier’s account, and declined to admit the stock register and affidavit as additional evidence without a formal application showing reasonable cause.

➡️ The supplier’s valid registration on the transaction date, its filing of returns and the reflection of the invoices in GSTR-2B were held irrelevant in view of the finding that no business existed. The Tribunal distinguished Gargo Traders, where a valid registration was cancelled retrospectively, and Quest Merchandising under the Delhi VAT Act, where the transactions were not doubted, and rejected the plea of violation of natural justice as adequate opportunity had been given.

✔️ GSTAT Cuttack – Ram Niwas Agarwal Vs Dhirendra Kumar Parida- Addl. Commissioner Of State Tax [APL/55/CTT/2026]

This will close in 5 seconds

Scroll to Top