
LATEST GST CASE LAWS: 18.11.2026
🔥📛 SC issues notice against Gujarat HC judgment upholding validity of corporate guarantee; Stays demand
➡️ The Supreme Court issued notice in Torrent Power’s Special Leave Petition against the Gujarat High Court judgment upholding the constitutional validity of Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules and Section 15(4) of the CGST Act on valuation of corporate guarantees, and stayed the impugned demands until further orders.
➡️ The Gujarat High Court had partly allowed the writ petitions by reading down the expression ‘whichever is higher’ in Rule 28(2), holding that levy of GST at 1% per annum on corporate guarantees furnished before the rule was introduced with effect from October 26, 2023 is harsh, unfair and violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(g).
➡️ The High Court had, however, clarified that the levy is attracted from October 26, 2023 where guarantees continue, on the reasoning that the taxable event occurs every year, and had found no discrimination vis-à-vis the exemption available to Government guarantees.
➡️ The High Court had also set aside the CBIC Circulars dated October 27, 2023 and July 11, 2024 to the extent contrary to its findings, and consequently set aside the proceedings under Section 74 with a direction to refund the excess GST.
➡️ The Supreme Court’s notice is returnable within four weeks. With the Delhi High Court in Sterlite Power Transmission having also partly allowed challenges to GST on corporate guarantees on somewhat different reasoning, the valuation and retrospective reach of Rule 28(2) will now be settled by the Supreme Court, and group companies should keep such demands in protest pending the outcome.
✔️ SC – Torrent Power Ltd vs Union of India & Ors [Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s).38244/2026]
🔥📛 SC judgment that mere foundation fixation does not render solar systems immovable; 70:30 ratio optional
➡️ The Supreme Court held that, in turnkey EPC contracts for supply and installation of Solar Power Generating Systems, mere fixation of the system to civil foundations does not render it immovable property so as to make the transaction a works contract, and set aside the orders of the Joint Commissioner and Superintendent raising a demand of ₹53.3 crore including penalty.
➡️ The assessee had paid GST at 5%, treating the system as goods under Sl. No. 234 of Schedule I to Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate). The Joint Commissioner treated the supply as a works contract, applied 5% on 70% and 18% on 30% of the value, invoked the extended period under Section 74 and imposed penalty under Section 122(2)(b). Although the High Court had dismissed the writ on the ground of alternate remedy, the Supreme Court observed that this bar is not a straitjacket formula and decided the dispute on merits.
➡️ The Court held that the 70:30 valuation mechanism introduced from January 1, 2019 cannot be compulsorily extended to pre-existing transactions. Neither Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate) nor Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST mandates such application; the circular’s wording that tax ‘can’ be paid in that ratio shows the choice rested with assessees, and the Revenue’s view that it applies across the board was termed patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable.
➡️ Since the 70:30 regime did not exist before January 1, 2019, the Court held that the question of imputing fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression does not arise, and that invocation of the extended period under Section 74 was completely unsustainable on facts and in law, relying on Tata Steel.
➡️ On the works contract issue, the Court approved the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s view in the assessee’s own case, Siemens Gamesa and Arka Green Power. Applying the Bharti Airtel tests of nature and object of annexation, intention, functionality, permanency and marketability, it held that not every composite supply is a works contract, which must result in immovable property as the end product. The system can be detached and used elsewhere, the foundation merely keeps it stable, and the presence of civil work in the contract does not by itself make the supply a works contract. Reliance on Rudraksha Allied Chemicals was rejected.
✔️ SC – Sterling And Wilson Pvt Ltd vs UOI & ors [Special Leave Petition (C) No. 23844 of 2025]
🔥📛 AAR: Promoter’s maintenance services to flat owners taxable despite statutory obligation
➡️ The Maharashtra AAR held that maintenance services provided by a promoter to flat owners constitute a ‘supply’ under Section 7 of the GST Act and are taxable, even though they are undertaken pursuant to a statutory obligation under the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act, 1963 (MOFA).
➡️ The applicant, Vardhaman Homes, had sold flats to various buyers under registered agreements for sale or deeds of conveyance, and sought a ruling on its liability to pay tax on the maintenance charges it collects from the flat owners.
➡️ The AAR ruled that advance maintenance collected is advance consideration for the supply of maintenance services, taxable under Section 13, so that the GST liability arises at the time of receipt of the advance.
➡️ The AAR observed that under GST all goods and services are taxable unless specifically exempted, that only services notified in Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) are exempt, and that there is no exemption for activities performed under a statutory obligation. MOFA governs civil obligations while GST governs the taxability of supply, so the two statutes operate in different fields and the MOFA obligation does not negate GST liability.
➡️ The absence of a co-operative housing society, company or resident welfare association does not affect taxability. The exemption under Entry No. 77 of Notification No. 12/2017 for maintenance contributions up to ₹7,500 per member per month was held inapplicable, because the applicant is a promoter and not an RWA or housing society.
✔️ Maharashtra AAR – In the matter of Ms Vardhaman Homes (Applicant) [NO.GST-ARA- 54/2022-23/B- 157]
🔥📛 AAR: Ready-Mix-Concrete processing using contractor-owned inputs is ‘job work’ despite emergence of distinct product
➡️ The Maharashtra AAR held that supplying Ready-Mix Concrete (RMC) at the construction site under a work order, where the contractor supplies all principal inputs free of cost, is not a supply of goods but a supply of services by way of treatment or processing of goods belonging to another registered person, classifiable under SAC 998853 as other non-metallic mineral product manufacturing services.
➡️ The applicant sets up and operates an RMC batching plant at the project site of the contractor, Riverview City Constructions Limited, for its township project. The contractor supplies cement, sand, aggregates, water and admixtures free of cost, while the applicant carries out weighing, batching, mixing, processing and primary transportation using its own plant, manpower, fuel and power, and bears the operational expenses.
➡️ The AAR ruled that the activity qualifies as ‘job work’ under Section 2(68) because all three conditions are met: the applicant undertakes substantial processing, ownership of the contractor’s goods is never transferred to it, and the contractor is a registered person. Merely because a commercially distinct product emerges at the end of the process, the activity does not cease to be job work, consistent with the Supreme Court’s ruling in Prestige Engineering.
➡️ The AAR clarified that under GST the taxable event is supply and not manufacture, and that even where an activity amounts to manufacture in a commercial sense, Para 3 of Schedule II treats it as a supply of services when carried out on another person’s goods. Excise jurisprudence is relevant only to show that a distinct product emerges. On Circular No. 38/12/2018-GST, it held that the operational expenses borne by the applicant are facilitating inputs that do not affect ownership of the principal goods.
➡️ On the rate, the AAR distinguished Sl. No. 26(id) of the Rate Notification, covering job work, from the residual Sl. No. 26(iv), holding that once the transaction satisfies the definition of job work recourse to the residual entry is not permissible. The applicable rate is 12% for the period before September 22, 2025 and 18% thereafter, following Notification No. 15/2025-Central Tax (Rate).
✔️ Maharashtra AAR – In the matter of Prayatna Infratech Pvt. Ltd [NO.GST-ARA- 52/2022-23/B- 156]
🔥📛 AAR: Promotional goods distributed against reward points not taxable; ITC blocked under section 17(5)(h)
➡️ The Maharashtra AAR held that the transfer of promotional goods to dealers, retailers and others against redemption of reward points under the applicant’s ‘Dhan Barse Scheme’ does not constitute a supply under Section 7 of the CGST Act, as the goods are transferred without consideration.
➡️ The AAR observed that reward points merely serve as a mechanism to identify the persons eligible for rewards and do not constitute actionable claims against the applicant, since the scheme creates no contractual obligation to provide the rewards, which remain at the applicant’s discretion.
➡️ The promotional goods, which include cars, motorcycles, refrigerators and mobile phones, are voluntarily provided as incentives for purchases and brand loyalty and therefore qualify as gifts. Accordingly, GST is not payable on the transfer of such goods against redemption of reward points.
➡️ ITC of the GST paid on procurement of these goods was, however, denied under Section 17(5)(h), on the reasoning that the goods are disposed of by way of gift and that the non obstante clause in the provision overrides the general entitlement to credit under Section 16(1).
➡️ The AAR distinguished CBIC Circular No. 92/11/2019-GST dated March 7, 2019, clarifying that its treatment of ‘Buy One, Get One Free’ offers and post-supply discounts does not extend to promotional goods independently procured and distributed as gifts under a reward scheme. Businesses running loyalty schemes must therefore treat the credit on reward items as a cost.
✔️ Maharashtra AAR – In the matter of Goldmedal Electricals Pvt. Ltd [NO. GST-ARA- 37/2021-22/B-151]
🔥📛 AAR: Laboratory testing charges collected by agricultural university from students exempt; External testing services taxable at 18%
➡️ The Maharashtra AAR held that laboratory testing services provided by Mahatma Phule Krishi Vidyapeeth to its students, research scholars and faculty members as part of the academic curriculum and research activities are exempt from GST under Entry 66(a) of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
➡️ Testing services provided to farmers, government departments, private companies and the public were, however, held taxable, as they do not qualify for exemption under Entries 4, 5, 54(a) or 54(f) of the Notification.
➡️ The applicant, a statutory agricultural university, undertakes soil, water, seed, plant pathology and other laboratory tests and collects charges for them. The AAR held that these activities constitute a supply of services under Section 7(1), being undertaken in the course or furtherance of business within the inclusive scope of Section 2(17) irrespective of pecuniary benefit, with the fees constituting consideration.
➡️ The external testing services are not covered by Entries 4 and 5 because they are not provided in relation to functions entrusted to Panchayats or Municipalities under Articles 243G and 243W. Entry 54(a) does not apply as the tests are not directly related to agricultural operations for production of agricultural produce, and Entry 54(f) does not apply as they do not involve farmer education or training through application of scientific research to agricultural practices.
➡️ Such services were classified under SAC 998346 as Technical Testing and Analysis Services, taxable at 18% (9% CGST and 9% SGST). Universities and research institutions must therefore separate curriculum-related testing for their own students from paid testing for outside parties.
✔️ Maharashtra AAR – In the matter of Mahatma Phule Krishi Vidyapeeth, Rahuri [NO.GST-ARA- 01/2021-22/B-155]
🔥📛 AAR: ITC reversible on batteries/cells damaged due to flood u/s 17(5)(h) to extent of value-reduction
➡️ The Maharashtra AAR ruled that the applicant must reverse ITC attributable to batteries and cells damaged by flood or inundation under Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act, to the extent of the reduction in value of the goods.
➡️ The applicant’s major raw materials were sealed lead acid batteries and nickel cells under HSN 8507, procured indigenously or imported at 28% with ITC availed. It sought a ruling on whether ITC must be reversed to the extent of the value reduction caused by flood water, and whether any GST is payable on receipt of an insurance settlement of ₹74,58,282.
➡️ The AAR observed that this was not a normal market-driven price reduction or obsolescence but a specific, identifiable loss due to flood for which insurance compensation was claimed and received. Section 17(5)(h) is intended to deny ITC where goods do not ultimately contribute fully to taxable outward supply because of loss or destruction, and flood is an extraneous and abnormal event that cannot be equated with normal business depreciation.
➡️ Receipt of the insurance claim was held not to be a ‘supply’ under Section 7, since the payout is compensation for loss or damage to goods and not a payment for any goods or services provided to the insurer, and it therefore attracts no GST liability.
➡️ The AAR held that the value of the insurance claim received represents the value of goods written off, which is covered by Section 17(5)(h), so the ITC attributable to it must be reversed. The reversal is to be made in the return for the period in which the loss becomes known or is recognised in the books, whichever is earlier.
✔️ Maharashtra AAR – In the matter of (Prime Products) Tarun Madhukant Desai HUF [NO.GST-ARA- 35/2022-23/B- 152]
🔥📛 GSTAT: FAA must examine appeal records despite non-appearance; GSTR-2A mismatch alone cannot sustain ITC demand
➡️ GSTAT Bengaluru set aside the First Appellate Authority’s order dismissing the assessee’s appeal for non-appearance, holding that it is the appellate authority’s statutory duty under Sections 107(11) and (12) of the CGST Act to decide the appeal on merits by a reasoned order, and that even where the appellant does not appear it must give findings on the grounds and examine the documents filed with the appeal.
➡️ The assessee had filed a detailed appeal, including its DRC-06 reply, grounds under Section 16, an ITC reconciliation statement and B2BA entries explaining the mismatch between GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A for FY 2018-19. The Tribunal held that a general statement that the appellant did not adduce necessary documentary evidence cannot replace an examination of material already on record, and the authority was required to identify any specific deficiency.
➡️ Rejecting the Revenue’s reliance on the Supreme Court’s decision in B.N. Bhattacharjee and other rulings on the need to pursue an appeal effectively, the Tribunal observed that such decisions may justify proceeding without further adjournments but cannot justify a non-speaking dismissal that omits the points for determination, findings and reasons mandated by Section 107(12).
➡️ On merits, referring to Section 16 as it then stood and the decision in Peekay Industries, the Tribunal ruled that a mismatch between ITC availed in GSTR-3B and ITC available in GSTR-2A alone does not create a tax liability. The Revenue had neither undertaken invoice-level verification nor found that the excess arose from a supplier’s default, and had not given the assessee the details of defaulting suppliers as required by Para 4.1 of Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST.
➡️ The Tribunal noted that the adjudicating authority had relied only on the B2B table of GSTR-2A for July 2019 and ignored the entries in the B2BA amendment table, which would have come to light had invoice-wise details been called for. It found no excess availment of ITC under the IGST head for FY 2018-19 and held that an order based merely on a period-wise comparison of totals cannot be sustained.
✔️ GSTAT Bengaluru – Optiv Trading India Private Limited vs Commissioner of Commercial Taxes [APPEAL NO: APL/37/BUR/2026]
🔥📛 Delhi HC-judgment upholding GST on corporate guarantee; Reads down Rule 28(2), limits retrospectivity
➡️ The Delhi High Court, in a 119-page judgment partly allowing a batch of writ petitions, upheld the GST levy on corporate guarantees, holding that a guarantee furnished by a holding or group company to a bank or financial institution for the borrowings of a related person is a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, even where no consideration is charged. The service lies in the guarantor assuming the risk of default and extending its creditworthiness, and it is neither an actionable claim under Entry 6 of Schedule III nor a security under Section 2(102).
➡️ The Court upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 28(2) as within Sections 15 and 164 and not violative of Articles 246A or 265, but read it down as arbitrary under Article 14 insofar as it makes the deemed value of 1% per annum a fixed minimum that cannot be displaced. The 1% value must yield to a lower open market value established through cogent and verifiable material, though a lower price agreed between related persons, or the absence of consideration, is not sufficient evidence. On this point the Court disagreed with the Gujarat High Court in Torrent Power, and it upheld the proviso deeming the invoice value to be the value where the recipient is eligible for full ITC.
➡️ On time of supply, the Court held that corporate guarantees are governed by Section 13(2)(a) or (b) and are not a continuous supply under Section 2(33). The supply takes place on execution of the guarantee and again on each renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement of the guaranteed amount, with the value of each later event determined by the period of renewal or extension or the amount of enhancement.
➡️ On retrospectivity, guarantees executed before GST and not renewed, extended or enhanced thereafter are not liable to GST. Guarantees executed between July 1, 2017 and October 25, 2023 are taxable under the valuation rules then applicable, without recourse to Rule 28(2) or importing its 1% value through Rule 31. Rule 28(2) applies only to guarantees executed, renewed, extended or enhanced on or after October 26, 2023, and the mere continued existence of an earlier guarantee is not a fresh supply.
➡️ The Court rejected the plea that a guarantee is a ‘shareholder activity’, holding that ‘business’ under Section 2(17) is transaction-centric and indifferent to purpose, and that OECD commentaries cannot govern the GST Act. Circular Nos. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST were upheld but must be applied in conformity with the judgment. The impugned notices, orders and demands were set aside to the extent contrary, with liability to be redetermined, leaving open issues such as the extended period under Section 74, pledge of shares, guarantees for overseas recipients and proof of lower open market value.
✔️ Delhi HC – Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors Vs Union Of India & Ors [W.P.(C) 2966/2024]


