
LATEST GST CASE LAWS: 16.11.2026
🔥📛 HC: Excess ITC carried forward in TRAN-1 cannot be recovered under VAT law
➡️ The Gujarat High Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeal under Section 78 of the GVAT Act, 2003 and upheld the Tribunal’s order deleting a demand raised under the GVAT Act on account of excess ITC carried forward in TRAN-1, holding that no substantial question of law arose.
➡️ The assessee, a trader in agricultural products, had carried forward about ₹20.49 lakh more ITC in TRAN-1 than the credit shown as available in the GVAT assessment order as on June 30, 2017. For the period April 1 to June 30, 2017, the Assessing Officer disallowed the excess credit and raised a demand of about ₹33.40 lakh including interest, which the First Appellate Authority upheld.
➡️ The Tribunal deleted the demand, finding no violation of any provision of the GVAT Act and leaving it open to the Revenue to proceed under the GST Act. In appeal the Revenue relied on Dilip Babubhai Patel and the Jharkhand High Court’s ruling in Usha Martin Ltd. to contend that the Assessing Officer could take the TRAN-1 credit into account while finalising the VAT assessment.
➡️ The Court referred to Rule 117(3) of the GST Rules, under which credit transitioned through TRAN-1 is credited to the electronic credit ledger, and Rule 121, which provides for recovery of wrongly transitioned credit under Section 73 or 74 of the GST Act. It held that it is for the GST Department to act under Rule 121 for any wrong credit availed through TRAN-1, and that the only remedy available to the VAT Department is to inform the concerned GST officer.
➡️ The Court further held that the Tribunal rightly found the assessee entitled, under the VAT Act, to set off the tax payable against the available ITC. Excess transitional credit is therefore a GST matter to be recovered under the GST law, and cannot be the basis of a demand in the legacy VAT assessment.
✔️ Gujarat HC – State of Gujarat vs M/s J V Enterprise [R/TAX APPEAL NO. 379 of 2026]
🔥📛 SC holds mere foundation fixation does not make solar power system immovable; 70:30 ratio optional
➡️ The Supreme Court ruled in favour of Sterling and Wilson and upheld the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s judgment, holding that mere fixation of a solar power generating system to foundations does not convert it into immovable property, and that the transaction therefore does not qualify as a works contract.
➡️ The assessee, engaged in setting up solar power plants, had paid GST at 5% on its turnover and claimed refund under the inverted duty structure, which was rejected. A show cause notice then proposed to assess the turnover at 18% as a works contract, raising a demand of ₹63 crore with an equal penalty.
➡️ The High Court had held that a solar power generating system does not answer the description of immovable property, so the transaction falls outside ‘works contract’ under Section 2(119) of the GST Act and is a composite supply. It distinguished Duncans Industries Ltd. and relied on Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd., observing that once the property is held not to be embedded in the earth, the question of permanent embedment does not arise.
➡️ In its open-court pronouncement, the Supreme Court further held that the 70:30 ratio was an option given to assessees and was not mandatory, so the authority’s understanding that the ratio had to be applied across the board, even to past transactions, was incorrect.
➡️ The 70:30 mechanism was introduced by Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate) dated December 31, 2018, effective January 1, 2019, which deems 70% of the gross value to be goods and 30% to be services where a renewable energy system is supplied with specified goods and services for a single consideration, under Entry 234 of Notification No. 1/2017 and Entry 38 of Notification No. 11/2017. The ruling is significant for solar EPC contractors facing works contract demands at 18% and compulsory application of the ratio to earlier periods.
✔️ SC – Sterling And Wilson Pvt Ltd vs UOI & ors [SLP(C) No. 23844/2025]
🔥📛 HC: Wrong CGST label on summons doesn’t oust service tax jurisdiction; Declines interfere with SCN
➡️ The Rajasthan High Court dismissed the assessee’s writ petition challenging a summons issued under Section 70 of the CGST Act and the consequential show cause notice proposing a service tax demand for FY 2016-17 and the first quarter of FY 2017-18 under the extended period, holding that the authority had jurisdiction over the subject matter and the period, and that the pleas on classification, exemption, suppression and limitation involve disputed facts to be decided in adjudication.
➡️ The assessee, a construction company operating a stone crusher, had undertaken earthwork, excavation, embankment filling and levelling under work orders and treated them as exempt under Entry 14(a) read with Entry 29(h) of Mega Exemption Notification No. 25/2012-ST. After a search under the CGST Act in September 2021, the SCN was issued. The assessee argued that a CGST summons could not be used to call for service tax documents and that the SCN relied on Section 65(97a), which was omitted from July 1, 2012.
➡️ Relying on Mohd. Ghulam Ghouse and Kunisetty Satyanarayana, the Court reiterated that a writ against an SCN lies only where the notice is wholly non est for absolute want of jurisdiction. Section 174(2)(e) of the CGST Act permits investigation or adjudication under the repealed law to be instituted afresh, and the power to summon under Section 83 of the Finance Act read with Section 14 of the Central Excise Act survives. Following N. Mani and Pradyumna Steel, it held that citing Section 70 may be a wrong label, but a wrong label does not destroy a power that exists.
➡️ On the omitted definition, the Court observed that under the negative list regime taxability does not depend on a named service category, so the reference is a flaw in reasoning that does not oust jurisdiction. On the works contract claim under Section 65B(54), it held that although actual payment of VAT is not the test, the authority must examine what material was supplied, whether property passed and whether earth dug from one part of a site and spread on another is a supply of goods at all, which are questions of fact.
➡️ On suppression, the Court noted that the activities came to light only in the search and that exemption had been claimed on three different grounds at different stages, raising a fair question whether the true nature of the activity was ever declared, and that a return merely citing an exemption entry does not disclose the underlying facts. Limitation was held to be linked to suppression and not a jurisdictional bar, and pre-SCN consultation was not required for a notice arising from an anti-evasion search. The authority was directed to grant a personal hearing and pass a reasoned order on each objection, with all issues kept open.
✔️ Rajasthan HC – Konasth Infrastructure Pvt Ltd vs Union of India & Ors [D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14068/2021]
🔥📛 SC: Issues notice in SLP challenging demand on inter-State stock-transfers held as sales
➡️ The Supreme Court issued notice in ITC Ltd.’s Special Leave Petition against the Telangana High Court’s judgment, which held that the assessee’s inter-State stock transfers of goods were exigible to tax under Section 3(a) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, and directed that in the meantime no coercive steps be taken against the company.
➡️ The High Court had upheld a commercial tax demand of ₹11,59,38,020 on the stock transfers. The assessee, dealing in products such as cigarettes, atta, biscuits, confectionery, paper and paperboards and stationery, had challenged the levy as arbitrary, without jurisdiction and in violation of natural justice.
➡️ Lifting the veil of the transactions, the High Court found it evident that the assessee had been effecting sales of goods from its warehouses to different States and masking them as stock transfers to avoid sales and commercial tax, so the demand was legal and rightly assessed.
➡️ The High Court rejected the submission that mere production of Form F forecloses further enquiry. Referring to Ashok Leyland Limited, it held that while the assessing authority cannot brush aside a duly furnished Form F, it may examine whether the declaration reflects the true nature of the transaction where material on record, such as statements of wholesale dealers, shows that the movement was occasioned by a pre-existing sale. Form F raises a presumption in the dealer’s favour but does not erect an irrebuttable bar.
➡️ The Supreme Court’s notice keeps open the question of how far an assessing authority can go behind Form F declarations to treat branch transfers as inter-State sales. The interim protection against coercive recovery will hold until the matter is heard, and the outcome will matter for companies with legacy CST disputes on stock transfers.
✔️ SC – ITC Ltd. vs Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (LTU and INT) [Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) Nos. 28364-28369/2026]
🔥📛 Orissa HC to examine validity of late-fee imposition for non-filing of annual returns absent prior notice
➡️ The Orissa High Court granted interim protection against coercive action to an assessee challenging an order demanding late fee under Section 47 of the GST Act for non-filing of the annual return for FY 2021-22.
➡️ The assessee had filed its returns under Section 39 but could not file the annual return under Section 44, and contended that the late fee was demanded without considering the pandemic situation prevailing during the relevant period.
➡️ The assessee argued that Section 46 read with Rule 68 of the GST Rules mandates issuance of a notice to the defaulter before a demand for late fee can be raised, and that no such notice was issued.
➡️ The assessee further argued that Rule 142 could not be invoked to recover late fee determined under Section 47 through a demand notice in Form GST DRC-07, and that the authority had acted in flagrant violation of the principles of natural justice.
➡️ Observing that these contentions require consideration, the Court issued notice to the Revenue, with the Standing Counsel waiving formal notice, directed that no coercive action be taken until the next date and listed the matter on December 2, 2026. The Court will examine whether late fee for annual returns can be recovered through DRC-07 without a prior notice under Section 46.
✔️ Orissa HC – Dhabaleswar Filling Station Versus The Asst. Commissioner of State Tax, Cuttack-II & Ors. [W.P.(C) No. 36375 of 2026]
🔥📛 GSTAT: Reliance’s SEZ-unit entitled to refund of unutilised ITC distributed by ISD; Dismisses Revenue’s appeal
➡️ GSTAT Rajkot dismissed the Revenue’s appeals and ruled in favour of Reliance Industries that an SEZ unit, as the recipient of services, can claim refund of unutilised ITC distributed to it by an Input Service Distributor (ISD), since the supplier of the goods or services cannot file a refund application for such ISD-distributed credit.
➡️ The assessee had filed refund applications under the category ‘any other’ for unutilised ITC lying in its electronic credit ledger, relying on the Gujarat High Court’s decision in IPCA Laboratories. The Revenue rejected the claims on the grounds that there was no provision for such a refund, that the judgment applied only to IPCA Laboratories, and that the Britannia Industries judgment was under challenge before the Supreme Court. The First Appellate Authority overturned the rejection.
➡️ The Tribunal held that the claims were for unutilised ITC availed on the basis of credit distributed by the assessee’s ISD, and not for refund of excess tax paid by a supplier. Referring to the Gujarat High Court decisions in IPCA Laboratories, Britannia Industries and Amit Cotton Industries and the Madras High Court decisions in Urjita Electronics, Platinum Holdings and McKinsey Global Services, it held that an SEZ unit cannot be denied a refund of ITC solely on the ground that it is not the supplier.
➡️ Emphasising that the law declared by the High Court is binding on all authorities and Tribunals within the State, the Tribunal noted that no contrary decision was cited by the Revenue. On the pending challenge to Britannia Industries, it observed that the Supreme Court has not stayed the judgment and that the Madras High Court rulings independently support the claim.
➡️ The Tribunal also held that Circular Nos. 17/17/2017-GST and 24/24/2017-GST, which prescribed manual processing of refund claims when the portal’s refund module was unavailable, do not support the contention that an SEZ unit’s right to claim refund is restricted. SEZ units can therefore pursue refund of ISD-distributed credit in their own name under Section 54 read with Rule 89.
✔️ GSTAT Rajkot – Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Rajkot vs M/s. Reliance Industries Ltd. [APL/29/2026; APL/33/2026/; APL/34/2026; APL/35/2026; APL/36/2026; APL/60/2026; APL/74/2026; and APL/75/2026]
🔥📛 GSTAT: ITC eligibility requires verification beyond annual return figures; GSTR-2A alone does not establish entitlement
➡️ GSTAT Lucknow held that an assessee’s claim about the availability of IGST credit cannot be accepted or rejected merely on the basis of figures in the annual return, and that the actual availability, admissibility and utilisation of the credit must be verified from the original records and the electronic credit ledger.
➡️ The dispute arose when the Revenue noticed a mismatch between the ITC reported by the assessee in GSTR-3B and GSTR-9 and the ITC reflected in GSTR-2A, and raised a demand with penalty. The assessee explained that it had inadvertently reported IGST credit of ₹6.7 lakh under the CGST and SGST heads in GSTR-3B for FY 2018-19 despite having sufficient eligible IGST credit, and that the demand was confirmed without examining the ledger and returns.
➡️ The Tribunal noted that the figures in the Order-in-Original did not entirely correspond with those in the assessee’s ITC statement, warranting reconciliation. Referring to the Kerala High Court’s decision in Rejimon Padickapparambil Alex, it held that a demand cannot be sustained merely because credit was reflected under an incorrect tax head, and that once the principal demand fails the consequential interest and penalty cannot survive independently.
➡️ The Tribunal accordingly held that ITC availed under an incorrect tax head may be allowed subject to verification of the relevant particulars, and remanded that issue to the proper officer for verification and grant of consequential benefits.
➡️ On the second issue, where one supplier had failed to pay tax, the assessee relied on the invoices being reflected in GSTR-2A and supported by invoices and banking records. The Tribunal held that mere reflection of an invoice in GSTR-2A is not conclusive proof that all statutory conditions for ITC are met, though a claim also cannot be rejected without examining the invoice, GSTR-2A details, genuineness of the transaction and payment particulars. As the assessee failed to establish that the supplier had paid the tax to the Government, ITC on that supply was denied.
✔️ GSTAT Lucknow – Ram Niwas Sunil Kumar vs Rakhi Singh, Deputy Commissioner, Meera Bai Marg Lucknow & Ors. [APL/106/LCK/2026]


